Understanding ESD Risk in Electronics
Electrostatic discharge is invisible but can be devastating to sensitive electronics. Understanding the fundamentals is essential for building effective protection.
What is ESD?
Electrostatic discharge is the sudden flow of electricity between two objects with different electrical potentials. It occurs when:
- Charged object contacts or comes close to another object
- Charge buildup overcomes air resistance
- Sudden discharge can reach thousands of volts
How Electronics Are Damaged
- Catastrophic failure: Component is immediately destroyed—easy to detect
- Latent damage: Component is weakened but still works—fails later in the field
- Upset: Temporary malfunction during discharge event
Latent failures are particularly insidious—products pass testing but fail prematurely, damaging brand reputation.
Component Sensitivity
Different components have different sensitivity thresholds (Human Body Model):
| Component Type | Sensitivity Threshold |
|---|---|
| CMOS ICs | 100-200V |
| MOSFET transistors | 10-100V |
| JFET transistors | 150-7000V |
| Op-amps | 200-2500V |
| Film resistors | 300-3000V |
Common Charge Generation
- Walking across carpet: 1,500-35,000V
- Walking across vinyl floor: 250-12,000V
- Opening plastic bag: 1,200-20,000V
- Removing tape from package: 9,000-15,000V
ESD Protective Packaging Types
Different packaging materials provide different levels of ESD protection. Selection depends on product sensitivity and supply chain exposure.
Antistatic (Pink/Dissipative)
- Prevents charge generation from packaging material itself
- Does NOT shield from external fields
- Suitable for low-sensitivity items or inner wrap
- Typically surface resistance 10^9 to 10^12 ohms
- Color: Pink or red (by convention)
Static Dissipative
- Slowly dissipates charge to ground
- Provides some shielding
- Surface resistance 10^5 to 10^11 ohms
- Good balance of protection and cost
Conductive/Faraday Cage
- Provides complete electrostatic shielding
- External charge cannot reach contents
- Required for highly sensitive components
- Surface resistance less than 10^5 ohms
Metalized Shielding Bags
- Most common for shipping sensitive electronics
- Multiple layers: outer, metal shield, dissipative inner
- Provides both shielding and dissipation
- Semi-transparent for content visibility
Conductive Foam and Trays
- For component leads and contacts
- Shorts pins together to equalize charge
- Provides cushioning protection
- Essential for ICs, connectors, boards
Packaging Selection Guide
| Sensitivity | Recommended Packaging |
|---|---|
| Class 0 (<250V) | Metalized shielding bag + conductive foam |
| Class 1 (250-500V) | Shielding bag |
| Class 2 (500-1000V) | Shielding bag or dissipative |
| Class 3 (1000-2000V) | Dissipative or antistatic |
Want to see how Cubic compares to your current forwarder?
ESD-Safe Handling Procedures
Packaging alone isn't enough. Proper handling procedures at every supply chain touchpoint prevent ESD damage.
Receiving and Incoming Inspection
- Inspect packaging for damage before opening
- Open ESD-sensitive items only at ESD-protected workstations
- Ground yourself before handling (wrist straps, heel straps)
- Don't open shielding bags on non-ESD surfaces
- Re-seal bags if not immediately using contents
Storage Requirements
- Store ESD-sensitive items in their protective packaging
- Control humidity (30-70% RH ideal)
- Avoid storage near charge-generating equipment
- Mark storage areas with ESD warning signs
- Ground shelving if using conductive materials
Workstation Setup
- ESD-dissipative work surface (grounded)
- Wrist straps with ground connection
- Grounded floor mats
- Ionizers for neutralizing static on insulators
- ESD-safe tools and equipment
Personnel Requirements
- Training on ESD risks and procedures
- Proper attire (cotton preferred, avoid synthetics)
- Use of personal grounding devices
- Understanding of why procedures matter
Shipping Preparation
- Place items in appropriate ESD packaging
- Seal bags properly (heat seal preferred)
- Mark packages with ESD warning labels
- Use ESD-safe outer packaging materials
- Include handling instructions for receiver
ESD Risks During Transit
Products face significant ESD risks during transportation. Understanding these risks helps you specify appropriate protection.
Charge Generation in Transit
- Vibration: Packages rubbing against each other generates charge
- Material movement: Products shifting within packaging
- Conveyor systems: Non-ESD belts generate significant charge
- Handling: Each touch point is a potential ESD event
Environmental Factors
- Low humidity: Below 30% RH dramatically increases ESD risk
- Temperature swings: Can cause condensation and other issues
- Air freight: Very low humidity in cargo holds
- Winter conditions: Low humidity in heated environments
High-Risk Transit Points
- Sorting facilities with high-speed conveyors
- Air cargo terminals
- Customs inspection areas
- Last-mile delivery vehicles
Carrier Considerations
- Most carriers don't have ESD-controlled environments
- Packaging must provide complete protection
- Can't rely on handling procedures during transit
- Plan for worst-case handling scenarios
Seasonal Variations
- Winter months: Higher risk due to low indoor humidity
- Summer months: Generally lower risk (higher humidity)
- Adjust packaging for seasonal conditions
- Monitor field failure rates by season
Setting Supplier ESD Requirements
Your ESD protection is only as strong as your supply chain's weakest link. Establish clear requirements for all partners.
Manufacturer Requirements
- ESD control program: ANSI/ESD S20.20 certification or equivalent
- Packaging specifications: Detailed requirements for ESD packaging
- Testing and verification: Incoming inspection and process audits
- Training requirements: Personnel training and certification
Key Specifications to Define
- Surface resistance requirements for packaging materials
- Shielding requirements (where applicable)
- Humidity indicator requirements
- Labeling and marking requirements
- Documentation requirements
Verification and Auditing
- Audit supplier ESD programs periodically
- Test incoming packaging for compliance
- Monitor field failure rates by supplier
- Investigate any ESD-related failures
Freight Forwarder Requirements
While carriers typically don't control ESD:
- Specify handling requirements in shipping instructions
- Use ESD warning labels prominently
- Select services minimizing handling touchpoints
- Consider temperature/humidity controlled options for critical shipments
Warehouse/3PL Requirements
- ESD-controlled receiving and storage areas
- Trained personnel for handling ESD-sensitive items
- Proper flooring, grounding, and work surfaces
- Humidity monitoring and control
Verification and Testing
Regular verification ensures your ESD controls are working. Testing should occur at multiple points in the supply chain.
Packaging Testing
- Surface resistance: Verify packaging meets specifications
- Shielding effectiveness: Test Faraday cage properties
- Decay time: How quickly charge dissipates
- Charge generation: Does packaging itself generate charge?
Testing Equipment
- Surface resistance meters
- Static field meters
- Charge plate monitors
- Wrist strap testers
Incoming Inspection
- Sample test incoming ESD packaging
- Verify packaging integrity
- Check for damage that compromises ESD protection
- Validate supplier certifications
Process Auditing
- Regular audits of handling procedures
- Wrist strap testing compliance
- Workstation verification
- Training record verification
Field Failure Analysis
- Track failures that may be ESD-related
- Failure analysis to identify root cause
- Correlation with supply chain touchpoints
- Continuous improvement based on findings
Cost-Benefit Analysis
ESD protection is an investment. Understanding the economics helps justify appropriate spending.
Cost of ESD Failures
- Immediate failures: Scrap cost + replacement cost
- Latent failures: Warranty claims + customer dissatisfaction
- Reputation damage: Brand impact from field failures
- Investigation costs: Root cause analysis and corrective action
Protection Costs
| Protection Level | Typical Cost per Unit |
|---|---|
| Basic antistatic bag | $0.05-0.15 |
| Shielding bag (small) | $0.10-0.50 |
| Shielding bag (large) | $0.50-2.00 |
| Conductive foam insert | $0.10-0.50 |
| ESD-safe outer carton | $1.00-3.00 |
ROI Calculation
Compare:
- Protection cost per unit
- Failure rate without protection
- Cost per failure (scrap, warranty, reputation)
- Expected failure reduction with protection
For most electronics, proper ESD protection provides 10-100x ROI.
Scaling Protection to Risk
Don't over-engineer for low-risk items:
- High-sensitivity components: Maximum protection
- Assembled products with some sensitivity: Moderate protection
- Assembled products with low sensitivity: Basic protection
- Non-sensitive items: No special protection needed
Building an ESD Compliance Program
Systematic ESD management requires a formal program with clear responsibilities and procedures.
Program Elements (per ANSI/ESD S20.20)
- ESD Control Program Plan: Documented procedures and requirements
- Training: Initial and refresher training for all personnel
- Compliance verification: Regular auditing and testing
- Process grounding: Grounding requirements and verification
- Packaging requirements: Specifications and incoming verification
Roles and Responsibilities
- ESD Coordinator: Overall program responsibility
- Area managers: Compliance within their areas
- All personnel: Following procedures, reporting issues
- Quality: Auditing and verification
Documentation Requirements
- ESD Control Program Plan
- Packaging specifications
- Handling procedures
- Training records
- Audit results and corrective actions
- Failure analysis reports
Continuous Improvement
- Track ESD-related failure rates
- Analyze trends and patterns
- Implement corrective actions
- Update procedures based on learnings
- Benchmark against industry standards
Certification Options
- ANSI/ESD S20.20: Industry standard certification
- IEC 61340-5-1: International equivalent
- Customer requirements: Many OEMs require supplier certification